Why Your Email Marketing Is Not Working (6 Critical Fixes for NZ Businesses)
Graham Lockett
April 15, 2025
Email marketing should be your most profitable marketing channel, yet 73% of New Zealand small businesses report disappointing results from their email campaigns. If your newsletters are being ignored, your open rates are declining, and your email marketing feels like shouting into the void, you're not alone.
The problem isn't email marketing itself—it's how most businesses approach it. After analyzing hundreds of failed email campaigns for New Zealand businesses, I've identified 6 critical mistakes that kill email marketing performance and the proven fixes that transform subscribers into loyal customers.
The 6 Critical Email Marketing Failures
1. Generic Subject Lines That Get Ignored
Common Mistake:
"Newsletter #47" or "Monthly Update from [Company Name]"
Generic subject lines are death to email marketing. Your subscribers receive dozens of emails daily—boring subject lines guarantee your emails will be deleted unread.
The Fix:
- Use curiosity-driven subject lines: "The mistake that's costing you 40% of your sales"
- Include numbers and specifics: "5 Auckland businesses increased sales 300% with this strategy"
- Create urgency: "Only 48 hours left to claim your free audit"
- Ask questions: "Is your website driving customers to competitors?"
2. Sending Newsletters Instead of Value
Most businesses send "newsletters" filled with company updates, industry news, and promotional content. Your subscribers don't care about your office renovation or industry trends—they care about solving their problems.
The Fix:
- Send actionable tips and strategies your audience can implement immediately
- Share case studies showing real results for similar businesses
- Provide exclusive insights and behind-the-scenes content
- Answer common customer questions in detail
3. No Clear Call-to-Action Strategy
Many emails end with weak CTAs like "Contact us for more information" or multiple competing calls-to-action that confuse subscribers about what action to take.
The Fix:
- Include one primary CTA per email
- Use action-oriented language: "Get Your Free Website Audit"
- Make CTAs visually prominent with buttons and contrasting colors
- Create urgency and scarcity in your CTAs
4. Poor List Segmentation
Sending the same email to your entire list is like using a megaphone when you need a conversation. Different subscribers have different needs, interests, and stages in the buying journey.
The Fix:
- Segment by customer lifecycle stage (new subscribers, customers, past customers)
- Create segments based on interests and behavior
- Segment by location for New Zealand regional targeting
- Use purchase history to create relevant product recommendations
5. Inconsistent Sending Schedule
Sporadic email sending confuses subscribers and hurts deliverability. Sending 5 emails one week then nothing for a month trains your audience to ignore your emails.
The Fix:
- Establish a consistent sending schedule (weekly or bi-weekly works best)
- Send emails on the same day and time each week
- Use email automation to maintain consistency
- Plan content calendars 3 months in advance
6. Ignoring Mobile Optimization
Over 60% of emails are opened on mobile devices, yet many businesses still send emails that look terrible on phones. Poor mobile experience leads to immediate deletions and unsubscribes.
The Fix:
- Use responsive email templates that adapt to screen sizes
- Keep subject lines under 50 characters for mobile preview
- Use larger fonts (minimum 14px) for mobile readability
- Make buttons and links easily tappable (minimum 44px height)
The Email Marketing Success Framework
Successful email marketing for New Zealand businesses follows a proven framework:
- Attract: Create valuable lead magnets that solve specific problems
- Welcome: Send a strategic welcome series that builds trust and sets expectations
- Nurture: Provide consistent value through educational and entertaining content
- Convert: Use strategic promotional emails with clear value propositions
- Retain: Keep customers engaged with exclusive content and offers
Advanced Email Marketing Strategies
Email Automation Sequences
Set up automated email sequences to nurture leads and customers:
- Welcome Series: 3-5 emails introducing your brand and setting expectations
- Abandoned Cart: Recover lost sales with strategic follow-up emails
- Post-Purchase: Build loyalty with onboarding and upsell sequences
- Re-engagement: Win back inactive subscribers with special offers
Personalization Strategies
Go beyond "Hi [First Name]" with advanced personalization:
- Behavioral Triggers: Send emails based on website actions and purchases
- Dynamic Content: Show different content blocks based on subscriber data
- Location-Based: Customize content for different NZ regions
- Purchase History: Recommend products based on past purchases
Email Marketing Tools for NZ Businesses
Recommended Email Platforms
- Mailchimp: Best for beginners with good automation features
- ConvertKit: Excellent for content creators and course sellers
- ActiveCampaign: Advanced automation and CRM integration
- Klaviyo: Powerful for e-commerce businesses
Design and Testing Tools
- Canva: Create professional email graphics and templates
- Litmus: Test email rendering across different clients
- Email on Acid: Preview emails on various devices and platforms
Common Email Marketing Mistakes to Avoid
Mistake: Buying Email Lists
Purchased lists have low engagement, hurt deliverability, and violate anti-spam laws.
Solution: Build your list organically with valuable lead magnets and opt-in incentives.
Mistake: Not Testing Email Deliverability
Poor deliverability means your emails end up in spam folders, wasting your efforts.
Solution: Monitor sender reputation, authenticate your domain, and maintain good list hygiene.
Mistake: Ignoring Unsubscribe Requests
Making it hard to unsubscribe damages your reputation and violates regulations.
Solution: Include clear unsubscribe links and honor requests immediately.
Frequently Asked Questions
How often should I send marketing emails?
For most NZ small businesses, weekly emails work best. This maintains engagement without overwhelming subscribers. Test different frequencies to find what works for your audience.
What's a good open rate for small businesses?
Average open rates vary by industry, but 20-25% is typical for small businesses. Focus on improving your rates through better subject lines and list segmentation rather than comparing to others.
Should I use plain text or HTML emails?
HTML emails allow for better design and tracking, but plain text emails can feel more personal. Test both formats with your audience, or use a mix depending on the email purpose.
How do I grow my email list faster?
Create valuable lead magnets (free guides, checklists, templates), use exit-intent popups, offer exclusive discounts for subscribers, and promote your newsletter on social media and your website.
What should I do about low engagement rates?
Clean your list by removing inactive subscribers, improve your subject lines, segment your audience better, and focus on providing more value in your content.
Measuring Email Marketing Success
Track these key metrics to optimize your email marketing performance:
- Open Rate: Aim for 25-30% for small businesses
- Click-Through Rate: Target 3-5% for most industries
- Conversion Rate: Track sales and leads generated from emails
- List Growth Rate: Aim for 10-25% monthly growth
- Revenue per Email: Calculate ROI of your email campaigns
- Unsubscribe Rate: Keep below 2% per campaign
Ready to fix your email marketing? FlowMedia helps New Zealand businesses create email campaigns that actually drive sales.Get your free email marketing audit today.
Graham Lockett
Digital marketing strategist specializing in email marketing for New Zealand businesses. Graham has helped over 200 Kiwi businesses transform their email marketing from cost center to profit driver.
Related Articles
Why Your Website Visitors Are Not Buying (6 Conversion Killers)
Discover the 6 conversion killers that prevent website visitors from becoming customers and the proven optimization strategies that double your sales.
Social Media Marketing Mistakes Killing Your Business (7 Deadly Errors)
Discover the 7 social media marketing mistakes that waste budgets and damage brands, plus the strategies that build engaged audiences.